Hi friends,
October was a busy month for us. We went to Cedar City, UT to visit family in what was the longest road trip we’ve ever done with all four kids. Being with our family was a ton of fun, but the trip there and back was literally and figuratively painful. Thankfully we made up for it with lots of games, hikes, and yummy food with family.
We were busy the rest of the month with activities and Halloween parties. I’m already plotting how to get rid of all the candy once I’m done stealing the best ones from my kids’ hauls.
I also got to read a few good books including the newest releases from two of my favorite authors: John Green and Brandon Sanderson. These two books had little in common, but I really enjoyed both of them.
Let me know what you think about these and any other great reads.
Best,
Tonya
Hollywood, Ending by John Green
Rating: 5 of 5 stars
Recommendation: yes
Review: I’ve been a fan of Vlogbrothers since 2011. I’ve read all of John and Hank’s books and count John as one of my favorite authors, so I was excited when I heard about this book. It draws a lot from Green’s lived experience getting some of his books made into films in Hollywood. It features excellent prose and character work, as I expect from a John Green book, and is a little light on plot, which I also expect from a John Green book. Although I do have to give him credit for a good reveal at about the 75% point that I didn’t see coming. Green has a lot to say about art: how we make art, how art is marketed and sold, how we interact with art. He works through a lot of these themes through a movie-within-a-book plot. Our two main characters are cast to play romantic costars in a movie about Andy Warhol. I really enjoyed this book. It seems to come at a very appropriate moment in time too as I’ve heard a lot of conversations about the point of art lately. I recommend for anyone who is a fan of Green’s other books or is just interested in a good read.
The Fires of December (Hoid’s Travails #3) by Brandon Sanderson
Rating: 4 of 5 stars
Recommendation: yes
Review: This is Sanderson’s latest secret project. We’re up to six now, and the third in this series narrated from the point of view of Hoid, an immortal storyteller who always manages to turn up at the most consequential moments in cosmere history. We learn in this book that that is no coincidence. I largely agree with a lot of other reviews I‘ve found online that the first and last chapter of this book are some of Sanderson’s best writing, and I also wish that he would have kept that tone throughout the whole book instead of reverting back to his typical story-telling style with Hoid as the narrator. I really liked the world building, and Sanderson always sets up some great reveals for the last 25% of the book, but the thing that made this book work for me was the character work Sanderson does with December, who is our sole point-of-view character and protagonist. She is excellent. I’ve also seen a lot of people complain about the romance in this book, and I have to agree that Sanderson’s flirty dialogue is super cringe, even for me, and there were definitely a few moments where I was like, “Why are we doing this now?” I think it was the weakest part of the book for me, and I greatly prefer Sanderson’s other romantic plots in Tress, Yumi, Warbreaker, and even Stormlight. That being said, it didn’t ruin the book for me like it did others. This kind of felt to me like Sanderson is trying to jump on the Romantasy bandwagon, but the subgenre just doesn’t play to his strengths. Then I thought a lot about art and how sometimes authors get pigeon-holed into a specific genre, or subgenre, and how shouldn’t we give our favorite artists the latitude to branch out and try to develop new skills? I’m still not sure how I feel about it because I don’t want myself and other readers to start to lose trust in Sanderson’s ability to deliver a quality story because he’s trying to adapt and grow as an author. I don’t know what the answer is, but feel free to reach out to chat with me about it if you have thoughts. Finally, I thought that the amazing character work and echoing first and last chapters made it a good installment in the cosmere. I recommend for anyone who like Tress or Yumi as well.
Establishing Zion: Foundations for a Millennial Society by Lawrence Walters
Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars
Recommendation: only if you’re really into civic governance
Review: This book was written by one of my professors in graduate school. That professor has since retired as I’ve been out of grad school for over a decade now, but I wanted to pick this up anyway because I really enjoyed his classes and chatting with him about projects. I thought this book would focus more on practical governance issues, but it mostly talks about the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saint doctrine surrounding the millennium and the second coming. There’s lots of scriptures out there about the millennium and second coming and that the earth will be like thereafter, but to be honest, it’s one of the areas of doctrine that I understand the least and have the most questions about. That being said, this was an OK read. I probably wouldn’t recommend it for anyone who doesn’t have a deep interest in both the doctrine of the Church and municipal planning, which is super niche, so there you go. I hope this book finds its audience. I’m just not sure that audience is large enough to fill even the Marriott Center at BYU.
Rating: 3.5 of 5 stars
Recommendation: yes
Review: Kuang is an auto-read author for me, anytime she releases a new book, which is about once a year, I check it out. She has an amazing range from epic fantasy to biting contemporary fiction. This book fell in the second category and had some amazing insights into culture shock, learning another language, and navigating your cultural background. Our main character, Lilly, was born in China but grew up in Boston. She’s a freshmen at Yale and decides to spend her summer in a Chinese language immersion program in Taipei, Taiwan, in part to get a better understanding of her family roots. She learns soon after she gets there that Chinese-Taiwan history and relations are complicated, and that she was wrong in assuming she would feel a connection to the people and place of Taiwan. She also goes through some truly painful experiences learning a second language. This was the part of the story that I could relate to most based on my own experience as a missionary in Thailand when I was 21. Lilly describes how it is mentally taxing just to exist and try to find your way around a place where you can’t read any of the signs without engaging more of your brain and spending more effort than you ever realized you were doing when you left the house at home. She does make some huge strides in her language learning and cultural understanding that are underpinned by some intense family drama. A lot of this book felt like the plot was meandering at best, or nonexistent if we’re being harsh. I think that’s true of a lot of stories that are classified as “coming of age” that I’ve read though. I think this might be true to the real-lived experience of coming of age, so maybe that’s appropriate? In any case, I will continue to read Kuang, but to be honest, I definitely prefer her fantasy stories to her non-fantasy ones.

The Time Tax: How the Government Wastes Our Time, and How We Can Fix It by Annie Lowrey
Rating: 4 of 5 stars
Recommendation: yes
Review: This book is for anyone that’s been frustrated filling out their taxes, or who has had to apply for unemployment benefits, or Medicaid, or any other of a slew of dozens of federal programs that are intended to benefit our citizens but suck huge amounts of our time with bureaucratic paperwork and nonsense. This time tax, as Lowrey describes it, is intentional. Policy makers from both parties heap on requirements not only for safety net benefits, but for every interaction with the government. Lowrey points out how frustrating it is that we live in a world where we can order literally anything we want at the click of a button and have it appear as if by magic on our doorsteps days, or even hours, later, but that requires us to spend billions of hours cumulatively to simply figure out how much money we owe the government in taxes. Programs specifically targeted to help low income people are particularly and intentionally onerous, requiring that applicants prove their income and means over and over on multiple different forms for multiple different programs. This is one area where America is not exceptional at all. There’s lots we can learn from other countries that have made accessing public benefits for their citizens as seamless as shopping online. Lowrey highlights Lithuania as an example of a country that intentionally developed a one-stop shop for all of its citizens to interact with the government. Unlike other nonfiction authors writing about problems in America today, I appreciate that Lowrey offers some actual solutions too, though to be honest, I don’t see any of her solutions being picked up and applied because neither political party prioritizes making government less time consuming and onerous as a matter of policy. In fact, in its signature policy legislation of the last Congress, Republicans intentionally added more paperwork requirements to programs for low-income families like Medicaid as a means to drive costs down, knowing that many people who are eligible to receive those benefits simply won’t be able to access them because of the enormous barriers placed on accessing them. This is mainly reading as a rant review, but I’m not mad at the book, just frustrated with the realities that Lowrey does an excellent job illuminating and explaining. As someone who is a strong supporter of good governance and with expertise in administering federal programs, this book spoke to my real and lived experience. However, I don’t feel that I have the power to enact any of the needed changes that this book calls for including federalizing the administration of many programs that are are now delegated to the states, onboarding many government functions that are currently offloaded to contractors, and pivoting our focus to ensuring that all eligible recipients for a program can access its benefits instead of solely focusing on making sure that those who aren’t eligible don’t. I highly recommend that everyone read this book.
The Rise and Fall of the Artificial State by Jill Lepore
Rating: 4 of 5 stars
Recommendation: yes
Review: Jill Lepore is mad. This book is a rare history book where the feelings and thoughts of the author are worn on its sleeve and clearly communicated to the reader from the first page to the last. Lepore has not only a gift for broad and insightful historical analysis, but also a great gift for writing. I think most people are only fortunate enough to develop one of these skillsets in their lifetime. Lepore is another auto-read author for me, and this book shows why. I was particularly enchanted by a reference to another scifi favorite, Martha Wells's Murderbot, which was entirely for the point Lepore was trying to make in this book about the existential threat of a robot revolution, and an amazing scifi read in its own right. Lepore has a lot to say about the artificial state that we all live in but all had little to no input in creating. She describes it thusly, "Building the Artificial State required turning people into numbers and inventing machines that could turn numbers into data." and, "In the frantic years of AI development and expansion that began in 2022, the Artificial State, once largely an accident, became a matter of design." She actually spends the majority of the book assessing the science fiction stories of the 20th century and reiterating that our modern "merchant princes" have taken all the wrong lessons from the stories they purportedly love. These stories largely warn against building the types of tools that our unelected merchant princes insist must be built. Another thing that I love about Lepore is the message of hope that underlies all her work. She says, "Yet everything destructive that they have done can be undone by voters, elections, legislation, and judicial enforcement, and by a commitment to the self-evident truths proclaimed two hundred and fifty years ago," and, "The democratic governance of technology, instead of technological governance of humanity: that can still happen." I mean. Finally a book about AI that is actually well written and powerful. I love it. I can't put it any better than that.


















